![:)](http://www.bridgebase.com/forums/public/style_emoticons/default/smile.gif)
I was playing just now and my p held something like
AQJxx
KX
x
AKJxx
bidding went he opened 1♠ i responded 1NT he then went 4♣ at which point I presumed gerber and responded 4♥... he quickly left at that point and a somewhat heated discussion ensued with me saying 3♣ would've been sufficient
I can't remember what my P had exactly as hand was redealt when he left, but it was around that I think
so my question is:
is 3♣
- invitational
- one round forcing
- game forcing
and was my P's 4♣ bid valid?
Thanks
Eagles